munyul wrote:@Dreamy,
Why should original authors have absolute control over their work?
Because it's theirs!?!? But as Catpaw will tell you, once you place it in the public area are relinguish ownership.
I guesss my question is directed at the whole concept of owning ideas then. It only seems like a not so productive powerstructure to me. A powerstructure that does more harm than good, and thus should rather be fought than respected.
munyul wrote:What good comes out of it?
As far as the map is concerned, nothing good and nothing bad comes from it. As far as the author is concerned, a warm fuzzy feeling that your peeps care!
As far as the map is concerned, I am certain that some bad does come out of it, and I have already explained why. Creativity is hampered when one can´t act on inspiration, and the delay of having to ask can harm inspiration severely.
So I guess it is progress vs fuzzy feeling then.
Only, I (or, rather, anyone wanting to modify) get a fuzzy feeling if allowed to do this. So my way there would be both progress and fuzzy feeling, just distributed a little differently.
munyul wrote:I find it a very sad state of affairs that there are people that think that their ideas, their needs are more important than others! An original author may spend hours working on something and may be very proud of their work, I find it very disrespectful that you can't find 5 minutes time to write an email and ask permission to improve their work and waiting a few days for a reply is not the end of the world!
munyul wrote:Dreamy has openly admitted that he is self-centered (posts #13 & #25) and Catpaw has stated that it is everyone's right to do as they please (a self-centered attitude I believe). It is rather ironic that two egocentric individuals are trying to argue what's best for the community! oxymoron???
You misjudge me. I never said that I think my needs are more important than other people´s needs. I simply recognize that my needs are not any less important either.
If you want to call that egocentric, fine. But then you claim that dince I am egocentric I can´t genuinely care for the good of the community. That is just plain wrong. There is no contradiction between caring for oneself and caring for the community. Self-sacrifice is not the only path to helping the community, and I´d guess that it´s not the most effective one either.